Review on the new Wellsley Farms Peanut Butter at BJ’s *NEW SERIES*

This post may contain affiliate links, which means I will make a small commission if you click and make a purchase. Thank you for supportingMyBJsWholesale!Read our full disclosure policy here.

Hi, Everyone! I’m excited to start a new series here with you on the blog. After having you all take my reader survey( now closed) I found out that 50% of you prefer to learn by watching and that 90% of you would like to see me do reviews on products at BJ’s.

For this month I will be reviewing the New Wellesley Farms Peanut Butter and the Berkley Jensen Laundry Pacs.

So I will be two doing products a month.

If you have a product you want me to review you must leave a comment below.

Another thing is I am NOT getting paid to share my review with you. I don’t get a cut of the sales if you end up buying one of these products mentioned in the review.

I do have to say that BJ’s has partnered with me to provide the product free to try.

Each review will always have a video of the product. So you can choose to continue on to read about the product or Watch the video.

New Wellsley Farms Peanut Butter

My Review of the New Wellsley Farms Peanut Butter at BJ’s.

Pretty self-explanatory in all the ways we can use Peanut Butter. From just a spread on your sandwich to the delight in your cookies. This is a pantry staple many of us have in our homes and can be used numerous ways.

The biggest benefit of this product is the ingredients and the price.

We use this product in everything that asks for peanut butter from sandwiches to cookies to dipping with Vanilla wafers.

We have been purchasing Skippy All Natural Peanut Butter from the club. The Wellsley Farms one is smoother which my entire family agrees they like it better.

Yet, the Skippy Peanut Butter has palm oil instead of hydrogenated oil. And that is what would probably keep me going back to Skippy. The two pack of Skippy Peanut Butter 48 oz. is $10.99.

My family votes for Wellsley Farms though 😉

My rule of thumb when shopping for ingredients is I tend to buy items that have 10 ingredients or less. The less amount of ingredients the better.

This New Wellsley Farms Peanut Butter has 4 ingredients.

Roasted Peanuts, Sugar, Hydrogenated Vegetable Oil and Salt.

  • 7g of protein per serving
  • Gluten-free
  • No preservatives, artificial flavors or colors
  • Made in the USA
  • Includes two 48-oz. jars of peanut butter

The price is $7.99 for a 2 pk. 48 oz. each. That means each Peanut Butter Jar is only $3.99. We just had a coupon for it and because it is a BJ’s product we will be seeing more coupons available for this item.

It is comparable to Skippy. Who knows it could even be Skippy with the way companies pay for private labeling. 

It is super easy to spread not gritty at all. If you tried their Organic version it was quite pasty. This has a nice smooth creamy consistency.

My five year old and three year old loved it.

I have no complaints other then I wish it didn’t have hydrogenated oil in it. I like the price and the taste.

I give it an 9 out of 10!

You can purchase this peanut butter in club or use the new pick up and pay feature!

I would and I know others would love to hear your thoughts!

Have you tried the New Wellsley Farms Peanut Butter? What did you think?


Every Week Win a $25 BJ's Gift Card

Subscribe to our email for a weekly chance to win a $25 BJ's gift card.

Must open emails to be entered.

Powered by ConvertKit
This List  is the easiest & Fastest Way to Save the Most Money at BJs!


HURRY! Limited Time! Join BJ's for $40/yr & receive a $25 Gift Card When You Use My Referral Here25giftcardimage
AND Check out my BJs Ultimate Shopping Guide WITH Bonus PDFs of:
  •  Couponing Resource List
  •  101 Websites to Print Free Coupons From
  •  2018 Coupon Insert Schedule
  •  BJ’s Prices & # of Barcodes On Products
Get Yours Here. 

Total Comments (28)

  1. Monae DayDecember 3, 2016
  2. RanceDecember 3, 2016
  3. CynthiaDecember 3, 2016
  4. Diana C.December 3, 2016
  5. Diana C.December 3, 2016
  6. patricia caradonnaDecember 3, 2016
  7. Michelle C.December 3, 2016
    • TasiaDecember 6, 2016
    • TasiaDecember 6, 2016
  8. Susan P.December 3, 2016
  9. AmyDecember 3, 2016
    • TasiaDecember 6, 2016
  10. Loretta MekusDecember 3, 2016
    • TasiaDecember 6, 2016
  11. Ritamary M ViningDecember 3, 2016
    • TasiaDecember 6, 2016
  12. Tabitha DDecember 4, 2016
    • TasiaDecember 6, 2016
  13. JessDecember 5, 2016
    • TasiaDecember 6, 2016
  14. Carla ThomasDecember 5, 2016
  15. Tracey LewisDecember 5, 2016
  16. dorothy dooleyDecember 7, 2016
  17. EllieDecember 7, 2016
  18. Serge BDecember 7, 2016
  19. SandyDecember 14, 2016
  20. SandyDecember 14, 2016
  21. Teena SiersonApril 24, 2018
wellsley farms greek vanilla yogurt new item
Should You Buy Chobani Greek Yogurt or BJ’s Brand Wellsley Farms Greek yogurt?
Wondering how the Berkley Jensen (BJ's ) brand disinfecting wipes work? Check out this review on the BJs brand wipes compared to Lysol Wipes. #compare #reviews #BJswholesale #mybjswholesale
Lysol Disinfecting Wipes or BJ’s: Which Is Really Better?
BJs sampling event
Sample BJ’s Brand Items on 2/18 for their Special Demo & Tasting Event
Video + Review on BJ’s Brand Detergent Pacs Compared to Tide Pods from BJ’s Wholesale Club