I Tried Instacart for BJ’s & Here’s What Happened

It’s been a long time coming, me, a BJ’s member giving Instacart a try. I have a popular post I wrote last year when BJ’s partnered with Instacart.

I wasn’t a fan at first because the prices on Instacart were higher then in club. Well, I’m here to tell you I gave the whole thing a try and I’m sharing the good, the bad, and a little secret with you.

You will need a BJ’s membership to use Instacart with BJs Wholesale club. You can get a discount BJ’s membership here that’s only $2 per month.

It was a snowy cold day, and my youngest daughter was on day two of being home sick. Of course my kids seem to stay home on the days I have BJ’s trips planned. We were on our last roll of toilet paper, and I decided to see if I could try Instacart.

It’s been over a year since I compared prices and I was pleasantly surprised at what I found.

The website is very user friendly. I find it easier to navigate than BJs website. It was easy to find coupons and add items to my cart.

All the items I added to my cart were the same price if I was to walk into BJs and purchase.

This was exciting and finally makes sense.

Now I can justify the delivery fees. Except, myself and others in our Facebook group noticed something.

I have a video below of my experience. Otherwise you can scroll down for the review and questions.

Here’s What I ordered with Instacart.

  • Berkley Jensen Bath Tissue $18.99 · 
  • Meadow Brook Milk, 2% Reduced Fat $2.97 ·
  • Chobani Non Fat Greek Yogurt, Vanilla Blended $4.99 ·
  • Berkley Jensen 160-Sheet Choose-a-Size Paper Towels, 12 pk .$15.99 
  • Wellsley Farms Sharp Yellow Cheddar Cheese $6.49 · 
  • Thomas Original English Muffins$5.79 ·
  • Banana 3 lbs. $1.49 · 
  • Land O Lakes® Land O Lakes Half and Half $2.29 

Items Subtotal $63.99

Sales Tax $2.80

Tip $3.20

Had $50 in Credits ( If you refer 5 friends you will get $50 too. 5 friends is the max limit )

Final Price: $19.99

Now this for me was a really good deal because I had the credits. Which I had no idea about. Sadly each account only lets you refer 5 people. If you sign up it’s a great way to share on social media with your friends.

The delivery fees were waived because I used a code. You will also get free delivery on your first order here.

Before you continue on, I noticed there was a SIGNIFICANT difference in price if I went through BJs.com and Instacart.com . Meaning you need to go through BJs.com and hit the same say delivery to get the same IN store prices. If you keep scrolling I have pictures and explain this in detail.


review on instacart for BJ's

I chose the within two hours for a delivery time. It was awesome. I was notified when the shopper was in the store. When the shopper left the store and was on the way with a time they were coming. My order was set to be delivered at 12:45 and she was right on time.

The website is really lovely to use. I find it user friendly and easy to access past orders. You will need to create an account if it is your first time.

I was extremely impressed with the friendliness of the shopper. She brought my groceries right up to the porch and then brought the rest of the items in the bag. She first brought up the HUGE packages of paper towel and toilet paper.

She had her own reusable insulated bags. When you use Instacart at stores without bags you can choose an option to be charged for bags if you wanted to keep them. For me it wasn’t a big deal to have her unload the items right on my porch.

I was already on a high of having someone do my grocery shopping and deliver it to me.

Overall I recommend Instacart. If you need a break from grocery shopping, this is a treat. If you are unable to get to the store this is a life saver.

I suggest always looking for a free delivery code FIRST to save money. The tip in my opinion is well worth it. Now that I know the items are not marked up this is a great option.

After you get your order you receive another text asking how your service was. You can rate it by stars and easily leave a review. This way if you are not happy with the service you can let them know. I gave my shopper 5 stars. She was awesome.

I loved getting the text updates on when she was arriving. Instacart shoppers are not supposed to leave groceries if no one is home, so schedule when you know you will be there.

You can choose specific times as well.

BJ’s Wholesale club does charge a flat $14.99 delivery fee if you don’t have a free delivery code to use.


Can you use BJ’s coupons with Instacart? You can not use the BJs coupons in your booklet or through the BJs app with Instacart. Instacart has it’s own coupons you are able to clip. These are not always lined up with the same in store coupons.

Do you need a BJ’s membership to use Instacart? Yes for same day delivery with Instacart you need a Inner Circle, Business or Perks BJs Membership.

What Can You Pay With? The Payment methods with Instacart are all major US credit and debit cards, Google Pay and Apple Pay.

You can not use store gift cards or prepaid credit cards.

Will you still get perks rewards? You will not earn any perks rewards when you purchase items through Instacart.

Where can you see pricing for retailers? Like I said above if you go through the BJs website you get in store prices on Instacart. If you go to Instacart.com you will pay higher prices at BJs.

“Beneath the retailer’s logo at the top, you’ll see the pricing policy: “Everyday Store Prices,” “Higher than in-store prices,” or “View pricing policy.” You can read the full pricing policy on Instacarts website.

Look at the side by side where you can find the info on the pricing.

review on instacart for BJ's
This is what you see for BJs when you head directly to Instacart website. They do not say they have in store pricing.
review on instacart for BJ's
This is what you see when you access Instacart through BJs website. They say everyday club prices.

A side note I tried this for Aldi and both platforms offer the same price. I tried it for Tops Markets a local grocery store near me, and it has view pricing policy whether you came from Tops website or straight on Instacart.

So this is something to take note of if you are planning on using Instacart with BJs.

I would love to hear from you. Have you tried Instacart? Will you be trying it now after this review?

Any questions you have use the comment form below and I’ll get back to you.

MyBJsWholesale may earn a small commission via affiliate links in this post. Read our full disclosure policy here.

Total Comments (25)

  1. Pingback: bj instacart
  2. Steve Carder
    • Tasia
    • Steven in NC
  3. Louise Lyons
  4. Eva Smith
    • Tasia
  5. Pamela Garcia
  6. Lissa Crane
  7. Lenny
  8. Kathy Saho
  9. Patricia
  10. William Mackie
  11. William Gallerizzo
  12. Patricia Petro
    • Tasia
  13. RGjr
  14. Willinzeem
  15. John Swahn
    • Tasia
  16. John
  17. Laura
  18. Stephanie Radecki
  19. Peggy Hogan