We Tried BJ’s New Fall Themed Items- Here’s What We Thought

This post may contain affiliate links, which means I will make a small commission if you click and make a purchase. Thank you for supportingMyBJsWholesale!Read our full disclosure policy here.

My favorite time of year is in full swing. From the Starbucks drinks promotions to Dunkin Donuts Pumpkin Donuts freebies, and all the other pumpkin apple cider flavored items you can think of.

By the way, we just tried Apple Cinnamon Yogurt Pretzels at Target and they were not everything wonderful about fall. The kids despised them as well.

Today I want to share with you the fall items we tasted and tried. Don’t forget to share a comment/ feedback at the bottom of this post. We love hearing your thoughts, oh and that one minor detail- all of those comments on our blog posts are entered into our $25 BJs weekly gift card drawing!

Yes, you should share this post with your friends using the share buttons at the top as well 😉


Let’s get into all the season fall items to dip your taste buds into at BJs right now.


Save or Read now the FULL LIST of all the BEST Deals at BJ’s Wholesale this week HERE. 


Related: The Best Halloween Treats Available at BJs for a Limited Time


yankee candle bjs review fall items


Yankee Candle Fall Scent $11.99

My tip is to try different jars. Even if it is the same exact scent grab two or more of the same one and compare. Some of the jars have a better smell. That’s how I found my favorite fall scent at BJs- Apple Harvest. I love Yankee Candles and in our house with two dogs a cat and kids, and the natural smell of farm fertilizer every day this candle get the job done.

There is a nice $2.00 BJs coupon in the front of club flyer through 10/10 making this jar only $9.99. 

HURRY! Limited Time! Join BJ’s for $40/yr & receive a $25 Gift Card When You Use My Referral Here. That’s like paying $15 a year or $1.15 a MONTH! 


Apple Cider Donuts 6 pk. $2.99

If you live up North here’s a question for you, Tim Horton’s or Dunkin Donuts? Either one you choose you will love these apple cider donuts. As long as you like apples. The price for one is amazing. At our local Dunkin Donuts a donut just one single donut is $1.19!

At BJs, you get a six pack for $2.99. They are moist and delicious. I always buy two at a time because well they are just that good.

HURRY! Limited Time! Join BJ’s for $40/yr & receive a $25 Gift Card When You Use My Referral Here. That’s like paying $15 a year or $1.15 a MONTH! 

pumpkin tea cakes bjs wholesale club

Pumpkin Tea Cakes 16 ct. $5.99

If your budget only allows for one of the items we are sharing in this article, pick this one. It’s by far the favorite. I’ve brought it to different bible study groups, gatherings, parties, and everyone kids to adults love them.

The flavor is amazing without anyone spice to overpowering. Don’t miss these ones, please 🙂

Related: Halloween Costumes & Decor Roundup at BJs This Year

pumpkin spice loaf bjs wholesale club

Pumpkin Loaf 20 servings $7.99

If you are in a pinch and want something light and not to sweet this pumpkin spice loaf is for you. I really enjoy the bakery items at BJs and found the loaf to be a nice light balance. It’s super moist and has a nice mellow pumpkin flavor. The kids loved it too.

I wouldn’t buy it unless I was really in a pinch because I love grabbing my canned pumpkin deal at BJs and making my own for a lot less than the cost of this loaf.

pumpkin pie at Bjs wholesale club price


Pumpkin Pie 40 oz. $5.99

Grab some whipped cream and this pie is the best! It’s my favorite pumpkin pie I’ve tried. The crust isn’t too dry like other store-bought pies and the pie itself is nice and creamy.  My youngest daughter wasn’t a fan, she didn’t like the crust but everyone else in the family loved it.


pumpkin sugar frosted cookies bjs wholesale club

Frosted Sugar Cookies 18 ct. $4.99

These are my go-to cookies when I’ve signed up for one of the kid’s parties at school. They are always enjoyed and are peanut and nut tree-free. Which many schools require. Just think our parents wouldn’t think to buy something from the store to bring in, it was always homemade.

Not an option anymore.  BJs carries these cookies for each season fitting the colors. Perfect for school gatherings.


pumpkin bars bjs wholesale club

Signature Blondies Pumpkin Spice Bars 15 ct. $7.99

These were the least liked by the family. Personally, I was not a fan of these pumpkin spice bars at all. I didn’t even want to finish the bar. My husband said they weren’t bad, but since he has type 1 diabetes said it wasn’t worth eating these.

The frosting tastes a bit off and the bar itself was dry and a little tasteless. I would skip these.



pumpkin bakery items at BJs wholesale club


As you can see BJ’s has a nice selection of baked goods. I didn’t find any crazy pumpkin flavored items anywhere throughout the store. The ones I did find that we tried we really enjoyed and recommend to you.

There was one sugar-free option, which I personally have not tried.

bjs pumpkin loaf sugar free

Hill & Valley Pumpkin Spice Sliced Creme Cake 16 oz. $3.99



What are your favorite pumpkin flavored goodies at BJ’s Wholesale club?



Coupons powered by Coupons.com


Every Week Win a $25 BJ's Gift Card

Subscribe to our email for a weekly chance to win a $25 BJ's gift card.

Must open emails to be entered.

Powered by ConvertKit
This List  is the easiest & Fastest Way to Save the Most Money at BJs!

Show Us Some Love & Share

HURRY! Limited Time! Join BJ's for $40/yr & receive a $25 Gift Card When You Use My Referral Here25giftcardimage
AND Check out my BJs Ultimate Shopping Guide WITH Bonus PDFs of:
  •  Couponing Resource List
  •  101 Websites to Print Free Coupons From
  •  2018 Coupon Insert Schedule
  •  BJ’s Prices & # of Barcodes On Products
Get Yours Here. 

Total Comments (22)

  1. Mary W
  2. Joan
  3. Peggy hogan
    • Tasia
  4. Cathy
  5. Melissa Dunn
  6. Junika Jones
  7. Joan
  8. Marie-Elaine Geismar
  9. Marcy Kliszak
  10. Pamela Miller
  11. Sandy D
  12. Paige Shuta-Wernoch
  13. mami2jcn
  14. Kathie S.
  15. Suzanne Landers
  16. Joanne
  18. April Graham
Brita Filter
Brita Filter Vs. BJs Filters? Whose Cheaper?
Kids Review: New Hanover’s Wholey Cheese Compared to Cheez-It
The Only Dry Shampoo I Love & You Can Get it at BJs
wellsley farms greek vanilla yogurt new item
Should You Buy Chobani Greek Yogurt or BJ’s Brand Wellsley Farms Greek yogurt?
No Membership Needed to Shop at BJs! LEARN MORE