My favorite time of year is in full swing. From the Starbucks drinks promotions to Dunkin Donuts Pumpkin Donuts freebies and all the other pumpkin apple cider flavored items you can think of.
By the way, we just tried Apple Cinnamon Yogurt Pretzels at Target, and they were not everything excellent about fall. The kids despised them as well.
Today I want to share the fall items we tasted and tried. Also, don’t forget to share a comment/ feedback at the bottom of this post. We love hearing your thoughts.
Yes, you should share this post with your friends using the share buttons at the top as well 😉
Let’s get into all the season-fall items to dip your taste buds into at BJs.
For an updated 2022 version, check out the video below.
Related: The Best Halloween Treats Available at BJs for a Limited Time
Yankee Candle Fall Scent $11.99
My tip is to try different jars. Even if the scent is the same, grab two or more of the same one and compare. Some of the jars have a better smell. That’s how I found my favorite fall scent at BJ’s—Apple Harvest. I love Yankee Candles, and in our house with two dogs, a cat, and kids and the natural smell of farm fertilizer every day, this candle gets the job done.
There is a nice $2.00 BJs coupon in the front of the club flyer through 10/10, making this jar only $9.99.
Apple Cider Donuts 6 pk. $2.99
If you live up North, here’s a question: Tim Horton’s or Dunkin Donuts? Either one you choose, you will love these apple cider donuts as long as you like apples. The price for one is fantastic. At our local Dunkin Donuts, a donut with just one single donut is $1.19!
At BJs, you get a six-pack for $2.99. They are moist and delicious. I always buy two at a time because, well, they are just that good.
Pumpkin Tea Cakes 16 ct. $5.99
If your budget only allows for one of the items we share in this article, pick this one. It’s by far the favorite. I’ve brought it to different bible study groups, gatherings, parties, and kids to adults love them.
The flavor is impressive without any overpowering spice. Don’t miss these, please 🙂
Related: Halloween Costumes & Decor Roundup at BJs This Year
Pumpkin Loaf 20 servings $7.99
If you are in a pinch and want something light and not too sweet, this pumpkin spice loaf is for you. I enjoy the bakery items at BJs and found the loaf to be a nice light balance. It’s super moist and has a nice mellow pumpkin flavor. The kids loved it too.
I wouldn’t buy it unless I were really in a pinch because I love grabbing my canned pumpkin deal at BJs and making my own for a lot less than the cost of this loaf.
Pumpkin Pie 40 oz. $5.99
Grab some whipped cream, and this pie is the best! It’s my favorite pumpkin pie I’ve tried. The crust isn’t too dry like other store-bought pies, and the pie itself is nice and creamy. My youngest daughter wasn’t a fan, she didn’t like the crust, but everyone else in the family loved it.
Frosted Sugar Cookies 18 ct. $4.99
These are my go-to cookies when I’ve signed up for one of the kid’s parties at school. They are always enjoyed and are peanut and nut tree-free, which many schools require. Our parents wouldn’t think to buy something from the store to bring in, and it was always homemade.
Not an option anymore. BJs carries these cookies for each season, fitting the colors. Perfect for school gatherings.
Signature Blondies Pumpkin Spice Bars 15 ct. $7.99
These were the least liked by the family. I was not a fan of these pumpkin spice bars at all. I didn’t even want to finish the bar. My husband said they weren’t bad, but he has type 1 diabetes said it wasn’t worth eating these.
The frosting tasted a bit off, and the bar itself was dry and a little tasteless. I would skip these.
As you can see, BJ’s has an excellent selection of baked goods. Unfortunately, I didn’t find any crazy pumpkin-flavored items anywhere throughout the store. The ones I did find that we tried we enjoyed and recommend to you.
There was one sugar-free option, which I have not tried.
Hill & Valley Pumpkin Spice Sliced Creme Cake 16 oz. $3.99
What are your favorite pumpkin flavored goodies at BJ’s Wholesale club.
BJ’s New Gas Offer- 50¢ / Gal With Select Brands + Coupons Included .
The apple cider doughnuts.
I love everything pumpkin. Thank you for sharing the tried and true!
I have to get in and grab some apple cider donuts before ther are gone
Totally agree the tea cakes are SO delicious, but for some reason we haven’t been able to find them the last two years. Wish BJ’s would stock more of them!
I too make my own pumpkin bread. It’s in the oven now
Yum!
Not usually a sweets person but those donuts are calling my name!!! I still like the old standby 2 ingredient pumpkin muffins-so easy since I hate to bake!
Thanks for all the great info!
We love BJ’s Bakery! I have a special place in my heart for anything pumpkin, apple and cider donuts are sooooo goood! I am born and raised New England and fall with all that comes with it make me happy. I’ve been in Florida for 4 years now and its just not the same. Thankfully I am a great baker and can make all the things that i love if i can’t find a decent replacement here. Some things even homemade here just aren’t the same as New England.
Still no tea cakes at my store!
Yummy treats. Thanks!
Thank you for all your great tips
Wish dunkin donuts was in our town.
Thanks for this!!
Like you, I normally make all the baked goods here, and I try not to keep a lot in my house, because I’m working hard to lose weight.
That being said, sometimes I just don’t have time to make something to bring while visiting, it for unexpected company. It’s nice to know that these options are there….and tasty! I’m one of those people who think all the pre-made pumpkin things taste overpoweringly of nutmeg! It’s good to know that the BJ’S brand isn’t overly spiced. Thank you!
I need to find these tea cakes lol
Excited to see the giveaways.
My toddler just discovered Halloween this year. Earlier this month we found the 40 count Sensible Portions Garden Veggie Ghosts and Bats Sea Salt Chips — she went crazy over them in the store! Unfortunately, I think they are sold out now, but they were great for changing up snacks a little.
It seems all fall themed items tend to be baked goods or sweetened and I wish there were more savory items for fall…does anyone else enjoy pumpkin just simply baked or squash? Wish we could see more of these types of items. Less sugar.
I am definitely getting those tea cakes!! Thanks!
Mean gotta try the deserts.
Gotta the fall deserts.
Those tea cakes are delicious! Not over powering like the ones I tried at Trader Joe’s. Yummy!!
I am obsessed with candles and loved the great Yankee Candle offer. My house has been smelling extra good for a few weeks now. 🙂
We’ve tried the pumpkin loaf for $7.99 and it’s great! With a family of 6, 20 slices is plenty!
I want to try the pumpkin spice donuts. They look so good.
BJ’s has great pumpkin pie. It is delicious.
I tried the donuts and the tea cakes on your recommendation thank you for that they were both good . I cannot wait for your Christmas posts they really helped me last year with my shopping
Keeping an eye out for those apple cider donuts.
Thanks for the list, they all sound great! Can’t wait to get up to my BJs to pick up, at least, the apple cider donuts.
Just started really trying to get the hang on savings!
I love decorating for fall. And I always have fall scents in the wax warmer
I do enjoy their pumpkin pie. I usually prefer to bake my own goods but this is a good one to take last minute to gatherings.
Still no tea cakes at my store but get the donuts every week! I’ll keep checking for the tea cakes!!
Oh no! They are so good, I hope you get them soon.
I want to try the apple cider donuts. They look yummy and reasonably priced.
I will try the Apple Cider donuts but I really don’t like pumpkin spice anything
What is a tim Hortan?? Lol I have to check this out!! I recently brought the coffee muffins and the cookie platter!! Man is that a lot!! Will definitely try out the Apple cider donuts!! Thanks J’s for the chance to win!
Those apple cider donuts look delicious! I’m going to have to add them to my list this week 🙂
Thanks for the heads up. Will likely look into the apple cider donuts Brought 2 trays of the pumpkin spice loaf to a function last year and brought most of it home. The mixed loaf tray (other kinds) was very popular as were the hamentashen cookies at the same event.
We are having a small Halloween party for my daughter and her friends. I’ll definitely be picking up the apple cider donuts and frosted sugar cookies for the kids. I think I will get the tea cakes and pumpkin bread for the adults. ?
The apple cider donuts are a great buy!
I will definitely look for the apple cider donuts next time I go.
I buy the pie for thanksgiving , I’m not much of a baker
I love the taste and smell of all things pumpkin. I love it when you show us all the choices that are available to us. Thanks and God Bless You and Yours.
It seems everything fall themed has to do with treats and sweets wondering when they’ll incorporate fall flavors as healthy choices?
Love fall and love all the fall goodies that come with it.
I love the Apple cider donuts
Prefer to do my own banking
The donuts are pretty much a staple for a few months. Never get tired of them. Great with coffee.
I want to give the donuts and pie a try. I love apple cider but everyone else in my home doesn’t! I’m glad they don’t cost too much!
I will have to check out a few of these .. We tried the fall colored cupcakes and my daughter didnt care for the frosting with this one… And she loves their regular cupcakes
Pumpkin Everything!!! Apple Cider donuts are good too!
Oh those pumpkin tea cakes look so good. And we loved apple cider donuts too so delicious. Thanks for the heads up on all these goodies.
Peggy, seriously get the tea cakes before they are gone! They are AMAZING!
Shopped at BJ’s today (no samples of the items you reviewed, maybe because we’re in Florida & not feeling much like fall, lol). But…we did buy the tea cakes and Oh.My.Goodness, they are sooo good!! Thank you Tasia for recommending them!
Definately will have to check out a few of these for my hubby and father in law who lives with us. Me, I take canned pumpkin and add kool-whip with a little bit of cinnamon and wallah, a low cal, yummy treat for me. Try it, you can take vanilla wafer cookies or fruit and dip them in it to for a little bit of extra treat too. Just my little take on pumpkin.
They do have some nice stuff and very reasonable
You have given us some great ideas for items to bring to gatherings. With the holiday season about to take off, it’s nice to know I can count on BJs and you for great time savers.
So many great ideas!!