Is My BJ’s Perks Membership Worth It?


Wondering if you should upgrade to a BJ’s Perks rewards membership? Here is a side by side look to see if the upgraded membership is worth the extra cost. 

I am up for renewal for my BJ’s membership and have analyzed the options for memberships and the cashback programs. I want to break down the possibilities for BJ’s members with the credit cards below.

BJ’s Wholesale Club Offers two credit card options to save even more at the club.

You save 25% off retail grocery price- plus, when you stack coupons, you will end up saving more than 25% if you buy any of these seven items at the club. In addition, you will pay for your $50 membership.

What if the cashback would pay for your membership from one of these two My BJ’s Perks credit cards?

The bottom line is that the BJ’s credit card may not be as good as other cash-back credit cards, but it is worth taking a closer look at if you are a frequent shopper at the club.

PROSCONS
Up to 5% cashback on most BJ’s Purchases1% Cash Back Shopping Everywhere Else Mastercard is Accepted
Up to $25 early Membership Savings2 with BJ’s Easy Renewal®Not a high welcome bonus.
10¢ Off Per Gallon at BJ’s Gas® Every DayNot suitable for spending outside of BJ’s Club.
2% Cash Back Dining OutRewards come in $20 increments and can only be used at BJ’s.
2% Cash Back at Non-BJ’s Gas® StationRewards expire
NO ANNUAL CREDIT CARD FEE 
  

*If you want to renew your BJ’s membership for only $25, do so here. (It is not an upgraded membership and can end at any time.)

Should You Apply for a BJ’s My Perks Credit Card?

First, take into consideration the amount of money you spend monthly at BJ’s.  If you are a frequent shopper at the clubs, these cards will pay for your membership and more.

Let’s take a closer look:

  • You open a BJ’s Perks Plus Credit Card.
    Costs $55 a year. Receive 3% back on most in -club and BJs.com purchases.

Example:

You spend $150 a week at BJ’s. That is $600 a month. You will be earning $4.50 a week back. That is $18 a month.

Throughout 12 months=, $216. Still, the savings will pay your membership if you are spending $150 a week.
Remember that the rewards come in $20 increments, so at $600 a month, you won’t make the $20 increment. 

Let’s say you only shop at BJ’s for specific items and not all your shopping needs. Yet, you spend $200 a month there.

That is $6 a month. That is $72 a year. Your membership is still paid for. 

  • You open a BJ’s Perks Elite Credit Card.
    Costs $110 a year. Earn 5% back on most in-club and BJs.com purchases.

You spend $150 a week at BJ’s. That is $600 a month.
You will be earning $7.50 a week cashback. So that is $30 a month.

Throughout 12 months=, $360. Still, the savings will pay your membership if you are spending $150 a week.

Let’s say you only shop at BJ’s for specific items and not all your shopping needs. Yet, you spend $200 a month there.

That is $10 a month. That is $120 a year. Your membership is still paid for. 

There may be a few disadvantages compared to other cash-back credit cards, but the bottom line is if you are a BJ’s shopper, it makes sense to apply for one of these credit cards.

Currently, the interest rate is 28.99%.

SIDE BY SIDE COMPARISON

BJ’s Perks PlusBJ’s Perks Elite
3% Cashback5% Cashback
Ten ¢ off/gallon of gasTen ¢ off/gallon of gas
2% cashback on dining out and other gas purchases2% cashback on eating out and other gas purchases
1% cashback on other non-BJ’s purchases everywhere else Mastercard is accepted.1% cashback on other non-BJ’s purchases everywhere else Mastercard is accepted.
$25 Bonus Earnings towards awards for the first non-BJs purchase$50 Bonus Earnings towards prizes for first non-BJs purchase

BJs added an expense sheet here if you want to see if this credit card will be worth it using it at other places.

 

BJs Perks Rewards

This membership doesn’t require any credit card. You will pay $110 a year and earn 2% cashback. That is a hefty membership fee to get 2% cashback. When you reach $20 in cashback, it shows up on your membership card. When you checkout, it will say you have $20 to use, want to use it now?

If you choose to do so, $20 is taken off your total.

You can sign up for this one online if you want here. 

 

BJ’s Easy Renewal Discounts

Once you apply for any BJ’s credit cards, you will be auto-enrolled in the ‘Easy Renewal’ program. Your store membership fee will automatically be billed to your credit card when it’s due.  You receive a $10 discount with the Perks Plus card, while the Perks Elite card gives $25. That reduces your BJ’s Membership Costs to $40 and $75, respectively.

SIGN UP HERE

Personal Note:

Since I run a Frugal Farm Girl blog, I can’t leave this post without mentioning the fact of having control over your spending. If you know that having a credit card opens a door for you, don’t do it. Even though you will save money, if you are spending more money than you have because you can put it on a credit card, it won’t be beneficial down the road.

Consider if you can pay off your credit card bill each month. The interest rate is pretty high at 15.24%- 25.24%.

You can also opt for the BJ’s Perks Rewards membership that is not a credit card. Offers only 2% cashback.

Do you have a My BJ’s Perks Card?

Will You be getting one after seeing this info? 


Limited Time! Grab a $25 BJ's Membership deal here.

MyBJsWholesale may earn a small commission via affiliate links in this post.  Read  full disclosure here

Total Comments (18)

  1. Joan December 23, 2018
  2. Peggy hogan December 19, 2018
  3. Deb M December 18, 2018
  4. Maribel andrade December 10, 2018
  5. Mooka November 13, 2018
  6. John August 21, 2017
  7. Mary W June 9, 2017
  8. Matilda February 23, 2017
    • Brenda Johnson February 23, 2017
  9. Ketsie Vazquez February 22, 2017
  10. Diana C. February 22, 2017
    • Tasia January 11, 2019
  11. Nikki February 22, 2017
  12. Carolyn MASON February 22, 2017
  13. Brenda February 21, 2017
  14. Angela February 21, 2017
    • Tasia February 21, 2017
  15. Angela February 21, 2017

Reply